Insights lesenGespräch

Returns

Causes, not goodwill.

Ecommerce Returns Cost: Fix the Causes, Don't Fund Goodwill

Almost one in four online parcels in Germany comes back in whole or in part. Treating returns as a logistics issue overlooks the biggest lever.

4 min read

Key takeaways

  • Returns in Germany have hit record levels: almost one in four online parcels comes back in whole or in part.
  • The most common reasons are quality, size, damage and inaccurate product information, and much of this is avoidable.
  • The biggest lever sits before shipping: product data, buying guidance and analysis of return reasons.
Contents

Returns are part of ecommerce. Customers in Germany are used to free, hassle-free returns. For merchants, though, returns are one of the biggest cost blocks, and often one of the least understood.

560 millionreturn parcels expected for 2026 by returns researcher Björn Asdecker, a record high (2025: 550 million)University of Bamberg
~1 in 4online parcels in Germany is sent back in whole or in partUniversity of Bamberg
49 %of surveyed retailers cover return shipping costs in full, 33 % in partEHI, Shipping and Returns Management 2025

Fashion retail is hit especially hard. According to EHI, one in eight surveyed fashion retailers gets back more than half of its orders. In other sectors such as electronics or furniture, return rates are usually much lower.

What a return really costs

Return shipping is only the visible part of the cost of returns. On top of it come:

  • Outbound and return shipping, often both paid by the merchant
  • Inspection and reprocessing: unpacking, checking, cleaning, repackaging
  • Loss of value: seasonal goods, damaged items or items that can no longer be sold
  • Customer service: inquiries, refunds, complaints
  • Tied-up capital: stock that is in transit instead of ready to sell

For some products, a single return wipes out the margin of several items sold.

The cheapest return is the one that never happens.

Why customers send items back

The most common reasons for returns

Quality defects
Wrong size
Damage
Inaccurate description / images
Deliberate duplicate orders
Share of respondents naming the reason (multiple answers possible). Source: KPMG, December 2025.

The list shows that many reasons can be influenced. Quality expectations, size information, packaging and product descriptions are in the merchant’s hands. Even “bracketing” orders (ordering several options to choose from) can be reduced with good buying guidance.

Five levers for return rate reduction

1. Capture return reasons systematically

Ask for the reason on every return, with clear options to choose from instead of free text. Analyze the reasons by product, variant and supplier. This brings problem items to light that get lost in the average.

2. Improve product information

Precise measurements, material details, honest images from several angles, notes on fit and use. According to EHI, 75.2 percent of online retailers in Germany rely on detailed product information to avoid returns.

3. Offer size and buying guidance

Size charts per brand, notes such as “runs small,” reviews that include size details, or digital advisory tools. The goal is for customers to choose the right variant instead of ordering two to pick from.

4. Check quality and packaging

If quality defects or damage pile up on particular items, the solution lies with the supplier or the packaging, not in the returns process.

5. Design return rules deliberately

Free returns are expected and support customer loyalty. Even so, it pays to design the rules deliberately: return windows, notices before purchase, targeted handling of customers who send back conspicuously often. It is important not to alienate loyal customers in the process.

Include returns in the profitability calculation

Many shops look at returns only as a rate. A more telling view is the contribution margin after returns:

  • Which products are still profitable after return costs are deducted?
  • Which campaigns bring in customers with conspicuously high returns?
  • Which customer groups send back an above-average share?

This view often changes priorities in assortment, marketing and pricing, and it shows how returns and margin are really connected.

How to start with return analysis

  1. Capture reasons cleanly: A short, fixed list of options in the returns portal or on the return slip.
  2. Identify top items: The 20 items with the most returns, in absolute numbers and as a rate.
  3. Analyze reasons per item: Is it size, quality, description or damage?
  4. Assign measures: Add a size note, refresh images, change packaging, talk to the supplier.
  5. Measure the effect: After a few weeks, check whether the rate for these items is falling.

Even this simple loop often shows results quickly, because returns usually concentrate on a few items and causes.

Returns as a source of information

Every return tells you something about disappointed expectations, unclear information or weaknesses in the process. Passing this feedback systematically to purchasing, product data management and marketing improves not only the return rate but also the assortment and customer satisfaction.

Conclusion

Returns cannot be abolished. But they can be reduced significantly once their causes are known. The biggest lever sits before shipping: in product data, buying guidance, quality and consistent analysis of return reasons. Merchants who treat returns this way no longer silently fund avoidable returns.

Frequently asked questions

What is a normal return rate?

It depends heavily on the sector. High rates are common in fashion, while in electronics or furniture they are usually much lower. More important than comparing with others is the trend in your own shop.

Should I introduce paid returns?

It is a trade-off. Free returns are widely expected and strengthen customer loyalty. Before introducing fees, tackle the avoidable return reasons.

What data do I need to analyze returns?

Return reasons per item and variant, the link to order, customer and campaign, and the costs of shipping, handling and loss of value.

Sources

Inhalt

    InsightsIns Gespräch kommen