Insights lesenGespräch

Conversion

Abandoned just before the finish

Checkout Abandonment: What Payment Methods Really Cost

The cart is full, the customer is almost there – and drops out. Often the problem isn't the product but the last few steps.

5 min read

Key takeaways

  • Two-thirds of German online shoppers have abandoned a purchase because their preferred payment method was missing.
  • PayPal and pay by invoice lead in revenue share in Germany, but they are also the most expensive payment methods for merchants.
  • A good checkout shows payment and shipping information early, stays short, and is measured regularly.
Contents

Hardly any place in a store is as valuable as the checkout. Shoppers who get this far have decided on a product. Every abandonment at this point is lost revenue that marketing and the store have already paid for.

One common reason is surprisingly simple: the preferred payment method is missing.

67 %of German consumers have abandoned an online purchase because their preferred payment method was missingMorning Consult on behalf of PayPal, September 2026
28.7 %PayPal's share of revenue in German e-commerce in 2025, ahead of pay by invoice at 26.1 %EHI, Online Payment 2026

Which payment methods customers expect

According to the EHI study “Online Payment 2026” (EHI is a German retail research institute), revenue in German online retail in 2025 was spread mainly across three payment methods: PayPal at 28.7 %, pay by invoice at 26.1 %, and direct debit at 14.4 %. Credit cards and wallets such as Apple Pay and Google Pay come on top of that. Wallets are now widespread: 97.2 % of the 1,000 most important online stores in Germany offer them.

For most stores in Germany, this means PayPal, pay by invoice, direct debit, and credit card are the basic setup. Depending on the target group, wallets are added. A growing preference for European solutions is also interesting: according to a survey by Brite Payments, 51 % of people in Germany prefer European payment options.

Preferred payment methods differ strongly between EU countries, so these German figures should not be transferred one to one to other markets.

The flip side: payment method costs vary widely

More payment methods do not automatically mean more profit. The costs differ considerably. According to EHI, direct debit is the cheapest option for online merchants in Germany. The two payment methods with the highest revenue, PayPal and pay by invoice, cause the highest costs.

Payment methods between customer preference and cost

Popularity →
Popular but expensivePayPal, pay by invoice: a must-have, keep an eye on the costs
Popular and cheapDirect debit: promote it deliberately, e.g. for repeat customers
NicheRarely used methods: only for a fitting target group
ComplementWallets, credit card: widespread, especially important on mobile
Cost advantage for the merchant →
Simplified classification based on the EHI study "Online Payment 2026". Actual costs depend on contract terms and default risk.

Merchants who manage their payment mix can reduce payment method costs without losing customers, for example by placing cheaper payment methods prominently without hiding popular options.

The right payment method closes the sale. The right payment mix delivers the margin.

Other reasons for checkout abandonment

Payment methods are only one part of the picture. Typical other reasons for cart abandonment:

  • Surprise costs: Shipping costs or fees only appear in the last step.
  • Forced registration: Customers have to create an account before they can order.
  • Long forms: Too many required fields, poor usability on smartphones.
  • Unclear delivery times: Customers don’t know when the goods will arrive.
  • Lack of trust: Unknown store, no reviews, unclear return conditions.
  • Technical errors: Failed payments, timeouts, problems with certain browsers.

How to optimize your checkout

Show information early

Payment methods, shipping costs, and delivery times belong on the product page and in the cart, not just in the last step. Shoppers who know early that they can pay the way they are used to start the checkout with more confidence.

Keep the path short

Allow guest checkout, reduce forms to what is necessary, and use address validation and autocomplete. Every step saved counts, especially on smartphones.

Build trust

Clear information on returns, delivery, and contact. Familiar payment logos. Reviews and trust seals, where available.

Measure instead of guess

Analyze your checkout step by step: Where do customers drop out? On which device? With which payment method do payments fail? Without this data, optimization remains guesswork.

Review payment methods regularly

Which payment methods are used? What are the fees, defaults, and chargebacks per payment method? Are your customers’ preferences changing? An annual review pays off.

Checklist for your checkout

  • Are all expected payment methods available and already visible on the product page?
  • Do customers see shipping costs and delivery time before they start the checkout?
  • Is ordering as a guest possible?
  • Does the checkout work on a smartphone without zooming and scrolling through long forms?
  • Are input errors displayed immediately and in an understandable way?
  • Is the cart preserved when customers abandon in between?
  • Is there an analysis of the step at which customers drop out?
  • Do you know the costs and default rates of each payment method?

Every question you answer with no is a potential lever.

Looking at costs and conversion together

A payment method that prevents abandonment can quickly earn back its fees. An expensive payment method that is hardly used, on the other hand, only costs money. So always look at both: the contribution to conversion and the cost per order. Only together do they give an honest picture of which payment methods pay off for your store.

Conclusion

The checkout decides revenue; payment methods decide completion and margin. Merchants who offer the expected payment methods, show information early, keep the path short, and know the costs of their payment mix get more out of the traffic they already have. All without additional ad budget.

Frequently asked questions

Which payment methods does an online store in Germany need at a minimum?

As a rule, PayPal, pay by invoice, direct debit, and credit card. Wallets such as Apple Pay and Google Pay are a sensible addition, especially for mobile customers.

Which payment method is cheapest for merchants?

According to EHI, direct debit is the cheapest option for online merchants in Germany. PayPal and pay by invoice are among the most expensive payment methods.

Should payment methods already appear on the product page?

Yes. Shoppers who see early that their preferred payment method is offered start the purchase with more confidence and abandon less often.

Sources

Inhalt

    InsightsIns Gespräch kommen